Skip to main content
AGORA
Draft for review. Not linked, not indexed, not in the sitemap. The board’s composition and the unit count need verification before this is published.
◆ Concept

Who decides your rent?

Two questions. Commit to a number before you see the real one, because the gap between them is the whole point.

Question 1 of 2

About a million rent-stabilized apartments in New York have their rent adjustment set once a year. How many people vote on it?

Not how many are consulted. How many cast the vote.

120people
0300

This is not only about rent

Once you have seen the shape, you find it everywhere. Transit fares, water rates, utility bills, zoning variances, hospital budgets. A very large amount of what government actually does to your monthly outgoings is decided by appointed boards rather than by anyone whose name is on a ballot.

The usual response is that you elect the people who appoint them, which is true, and which is doing an enormous amount of work. One vote, every four years, covering hundreds of appointments and every other question about the city at the same time, is a very thin instrument for controlling any particular one of them.

What would help is not a different board. It is a way of finding out that the meeting is happening while it still matters, and a way of registering what you think that someone has to count.

The two answers, in plain text, with sources

  1. Question 1

    About a million rent-stabilized apartments in New York have their rent adjustment set once a year. How many people vote on it?

    Nine.

    The Rent Guidelines Board has nine members and votes each June on the adjustment for leases starting that October. Two members represent tenants, two represent owners, and five are public members. It holds public hearings first, and the hearings are genuinely open, but the decision itself is nine people in a room.

  2. Question 2

    Of those nine, how many were elected by the people whose rent they set?

    None of them.

    All nine are appointed by the Mayor. There is a democratic thread here, because the Mayor is elected and the appointments are a known part of the job. It is a long thread. Between you and the number on your lease there is one election, held every four years, decided on a great many other things at the same time.